Groucho has left the building…

So this week, we were at a stately mansion in New Orleans’ Garden District and apparently we’re enough of a deal here to warrant the local tour guides to adjust their routes to include us.  (My wife took a city tour last week that devoted about 20 minutes to discussing the production and circling the set.)

We’re here at the mansion filming multiple scenes that occur here during the film with Dylan, Elizabeth (Anita Briem) and Marcus (Sam Huntington).  As many have surmised already, Anita is playing Dylan’s love interest and Sam is Dylan’s sidekick, replacing the much beloved Groucho from the comics.  A lot of people have complained about that replacement and I understand why.  (Hey, I was pissed when they made Chas into Shia Labeouf.)  It’s hard to see something you know so well and have for so many years go through drastic changes like that but here’s the reason why and it all boils down to one word: money.  For those of you who might not know, in the Dylan Dog comics, Dylan’s sidekick is an actor who’s last role was playing Groucho Marx and he kind of got stuck there due to a memory loss (finally revealed in issue 228).  He now lives and acts just like Groucho Marx.  Now, when we started developing the movie, we immediately started researching it and found that Groucho Marx’s likeness is owned by a company who has licensed it from his estate (no need to mention their names).  Such a place is likely to not care when an Italian publishing company starts using Groucho’s likeness in 1986.  Heck, it probably won’t even last, right?  By the time they realized it was going to last and it had become as big an international sensation as it was, the costs, in both cash and bad PR, would have been too great to make it worthwhile.  Besides, it’s not like an Italian comic book character would ever make it to the American big screen, where the real Groucho is so well-known, right?  So we come along, asking if we can make a movie with their character in it and they say, “Sure, it’ll just be seven figures.  Several of them.  Oh, and we want a piece of every image of him you use on anything, including any comics Bonelli publishes in the future.”

Well, as you might guess, we can’t really do that, especially at during the development phase when there isn’t even any money attached to the movie yet.  And try going to any potential financers and ask for seven figures just to use a supporting character.  So we have to plan for an alternative.  Our first thought was to replace Groucho with another, more acceptable comedian and get the actual comedian to play the role.  Like maybe the actor was playing Robin Williams or Roberto Benigni and we get the actual Robin Williams or Roberto Benigni to play it?  Well, then we’re painting ourselves into another corner by needing to get one of those actors in the movie.  And now we’ve got to be able to answer questions like “Why can’t it be Eddie Murphy?  We could get Eddie Murphy for you.” or, worse, “Can we make his sidekick Robert Pattinson instead?  Girls like him.”

So we made the decision to fight what battles we could win and not go looking for more that would keep us from making the film.  (There have been enough about Dylan driving a bug or wearing a red shirt, believe me.)  And so Marcus was born.  There are plenty of nods to Groucho in the movie, hopefully in ways that make the fans know we care.  Keep a lookout for the photos in Dylan’s office or when Marcus has to show up and throw him a gun from time to time.

Alright, I’m off to teach some actors how to fight.  Ain’t Hollywood a weird place?

-Dan Forcey

Development Exec/Stuntguy/SS (Spam Sculptor)

22 Responses to “Groucho has left the building…”

  1. Cynthia Says:

    It is just as well about the Groucho character. My generation would not be able to pick Groucho Marx out of a lineup — probably confuse him with Hitler. The sidekick ideas sound a little campy. Try not to be overly influenced by the comic. What works in a comic often does not translate to film. Good luck with the production!

  2. Thanks for explaining this to us. Plenty of people were P.Od over the fact of using someone else to play Groucho. Sometimes the situation requires facts to change so that Progress can continue. As long as the new character personality remains the same and the movie script is well written, I dont think it will matter too much.
    Keep up the good work.

  3. Dang I’m jealous. Work and New Orleans, all wrapped up in one.

  4. AntoBlueberry Says:

    Ok, Groucho won’t be in the movie. Btw, originally Sclavi’s idea was to have a Marty Feldman lookalike as Dylan’s sidekick, but Bonelli thought that a drawn Feldman looked too monstrous.
    What I want to know is if there’s at least Bloch, the commissioner who’s a father figure for Dylan.

  5. Stargazer Says:

    Well, just make the movie as good as you can, please. Do justice to the character, and please don’t just make it a mindless action flick. I want to see great characterization true to the source material and good acting as well. I’m really excited about this, and I trust that you all will do a good job. And thanks for keeping us informed!😀

  6. To Cynthia,

    I’m sure people young and old knows OF Groucho Marx. You have to give them enough credit. lol.

  7. deadofnightmovie Says:

    Going to have to be cheeky on this one and say you’ll have to see whether or not Bloch is in it when you see the film.

  8. AntoBlueberry Says:

    I’ll take that as “Bloch won’t be in the movie”. Strange, as I don’t think that Robert Morley estate would have asked for money.

  9. deadofnightmovie Says:

    In this case, it was a story thing rather than a money thing. I’m being cheeky because I can’t give too much away. You’ll understand why when you see the film. It has to do with how Dylan got from London to New Orleans.

  10. AntoBlueberry Says:

    So there’s hope for a sequel set in London?

  11. deadofnightmovie Says:

    We hope this will turn into a franchise that lasts a long time. But a lot depends on how much you folks like the movie.

  12. Stargazer Says:

    “We hope this will turn into a franchise that lasts a long time.”

    Yeah, Me too.🙂

  13. “But a lot depends on how much you folks like the movie.”

    Well, that depends on how good you folks will make it.🙂
    Fingers crossed…

  14. deadofnightmovie Says:

    Jeez, Dante. Put a little pressure on a guy, won’t you? 🙂

  15. Lol, naaaah….I think you know what you’re doing, no pressure😉

  16. Si!!! Non solamente esiste è anche molto ativa!

  17. la spiegazione è buona…

  18. la spiegazione è buona… mi accontenterò

  19. Indagatore dell incubo Says:

    Sure, we all love Groucho, and when Bloch is like a father for Dylan, so is Groucho a brother to him. He often helps Dylan to face the madness he deals with, Groucho is much more than a typical sidekick like Bucky Barnes, Robin or even Dr.Watson. The fact, that he does not appear in the movie makes me sad, but I meanwhile I can understand, that it´s quite complicated to get the permission to use the name and the character of one of the famous Marx Bros. I waiting sooooooo long for the DD movie, I really appreciate what you movie guys do, I don´t want to blame you for something you cannot change.

  20. deadofnightmovie Says:

    Thanks, Indagatore. I understand that it can be quite disturbing to see such big parts of Dylan’s world be replaced like that. I only hope Marcus becomes a second brother to Dylan in your mind.

  21. Indagatore dell´ incubo Says:

    I like Sam Worthington, so I am sure, he´ll surrogating Groucho very well! Is Marcus going to be a funny guy, too?

  22. Indagatore dell´ incubo Says:

    O-my-God! I am soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo sorry: of course I mean Sam Huntington!!!!!! Sam, SORRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: